Quantcast
Channel: Comments for Climate Etc.

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by jim2

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003779">burlhenry</a>. There is no reason volcanic cooling can't be superposed...

View Article



Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Ulric Lyons

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003779">burlhenry</a>. burl, fortunately, I had not seen your comment, the...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Ulric Lyons

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003777">aaron</a>. In the summer of 1783, the UK was engulfed in low altitude...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Bill Fabrizio

Can We Power the EPA’s EV Fantasy? https://www.wsj.com/articles/can-we-power-the-epas-ev-fantasy-electrical-grid-energy-vehicles-a786d535?st=q7pfe7sbqv19pr2&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Javier Vinós

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003811">BA Bushaw (ganon1950)</a>. That paper can't be trusted. Very unnatural...

View Article


Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Jaime Jessop

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003797">Javier Vinós</a>. Almost like the science isn't settled . . . . . .

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by burlhenry

In reply to Ulric Lyons. Ulric Lyons: The fact that England had a very hot July in the summer of 1783 is probably not related to the Laki eruption, but rather to a local heat dome. Most of the eruption...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by cerescokid

In reply to Bill Fabrizio. “ For EV enthusiasts, this overhaul is doable with the right amount of money. Yet they’re naive about the magnitude.” It seems the only thing that has an inexhaustible supply...

View Article


Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by J. Anderton

In reply to Javier Vinós. …”only about half of the 1980 ice volume remains.” Wasn’t the baseline 1979 ice coverage…? Right after a cooling period where they thought the next ice age was on the horizon.

View Article


Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Jaime Jessop

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003797">Javier Vinós</a>. BTW I was confusing the Schoeberl et al paper earlier...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by BA Bushaw...

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003825">Javier Vinós</a>. What papers of yours can be trusted?

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Ulric Lyons

In reply to Ulric Lyons. burl, the regional heatwave was exacerbated by the low altitude aerosols and dust, known as the “Laki haze” across Europe. The fog was so thick that ships stayed in port,...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by IL VULCANO HUNGA...

[…] del 2022-24 sono stati “davvero straordinari”, osserva il Dr. Javier Vinós scrivendo sul blog online della Dr.ssa Judith Curry. La rara convergenza di un certo numero di eventi “che potrebbero non...

View Article


Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by burlhenry

In reply to Ulric Lyons. Ulric Lyons: I don’t understand why you say that the following extreme winter had nothing to do with the Laki eruption. “Globally, 95 Mt of SO2 reacted with atmospheric water...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by burlhenry

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003814">jim2</a>. Jim2; I totally agree.

View Article


Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by The Great Walrus

In reply to BA Bushaw (ganon1950). BAB: From the abstract of your beloved paper: “To test this hypothesis, we use a global climate model to quantify the surface warming contributed by the SWV change in...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Ulric Lyons

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003818">Ulric Lyons</a>. SO2 aerosols don't cause such winters, solar...

View Article


Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Hunga Tonga...

[…] have been “truly extraordinary”, notes Dr. Javier Vinós writing in Dr. Judith Curry’s online blog. The rare convergence of a number of events “that may not be repeated for hundreds or even […]

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Mike

Thank you Dr. Vinos for a fascinating article. This winter has indeed been very warm in NW Europe as was last winter. Can you say anything about the timing of a reversion cooler? Do you expect next...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Javier Vinós

In reply to Mike. The strength of the polar vortex changes from winter to winter, but since 1997 it has been weaker on average. This means more heat enters the Arctic in winter, warming it, and more...

View Article

Comment on Mann v. Steyn: Round 2 by jim2

Germany is the crash test Climate Doomer “green” energy crash test dummy of Europe. Of course, this article wouldn’t dare mention the effect of Germany’s green energy push, including closing coal and...

View Article


Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by burlhenry

In reply to Ulric Lyons. Ulric Lyons: SO2 aerosols (a mist of Sulfuric Acid) ALWAYS cause global cooling. In the NASA Fact sheet on aerosols “Atmospheric Aerosols: What are They, and Why Are They So...

View Article


Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by...

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003847">Javier Vinós</a>. Javier - interesting observation on the polar vortex....

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Hunga Tonga...

[…] have been “truly extraordinary”, notes Dr. Javier Vinós writing in Dr. Judith Curry’s online blog. The rare convergence of a number of events “that may not be repeated for hundreds or even […]

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by...

Javier You made the following statement in the 7th paragraph. “The primary unusual climate forcing factor during the LIA was exceptionally low solar activity.” Do you have any insight in the level of...

View Article


Comment on Mann v. Steyn: Round 2 by joethenonclimatescientist

Given the frequency of hail storms in the US what is the real life span of a solar farm? 20-30% chance of roof damage within 15-20 years, while solar farms are much more fragile than the typical roof...

View Article

Comment on Mann v. Steyn: Round 2 by joethenonclimatescientist

In reply to joethenonclimatescientist. https://www.jsheld.com/insights/articles/solar-farm-hail-damage-the-perfect-storm

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Javier Vinós

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003847">Javier Vinós</a>. I am not aware of any studies on the detailed...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Javier Vinós

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003847">Javier Vinós</a>. <i>"Using cluster analysis, we identified...

View Article



Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Javier Vinós

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003847">Javier Vinós</a>. What they don't say, because they would be...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Javier Vinós

In reply to joethenonclimatescientist. From 1700 we have sunspots as a solar activity proxy. Since solar cycle length is variable, I like to calculate the solar cycle anomaly, by adding all the...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by...

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003859">Javier Vinós</a>. thanks

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by...

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003847">Javier Vinós</a>. thanks

View Article


Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Les événements...

[…] Article publié le 24 mars 2024 sur le site de Judith Curry sous le titre The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 […]

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Bill Fabrizio

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003830">cerescokid</a>. Kid ... I have a response in moderation. Thanks for the...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Ulric Lyons

In reply to Ulric Lyons. burl, the negative North Atlantic Oscillation episodes causing the mid latitude cold waves are discretely solar driven at less than weekly scales....

View Article


Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Petter Tuvnes

This article “Temperature” https://www.climate-veritas.com/?page_id=26 shows that global cloud cover has declined the last 20 + years, actually 40 years (NASA CERES satellite data) in the last 2...

View Article


Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Christos Vournas

In reply to Petter Tuvnes. “Green house gases play no role in the warming of the planet. ” It is warmed because of orbital forcing. – https://www.cristos-vournas.com

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Bob Weber

The attempt to link SSWs to HTHH a year+ later just doesn’t fly. What about in prior years when the UAWVC concentration was less? Before HTHH, in 2020/21, there was a SSW of similar strength as the...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Javier Vinós

In reply to Petter Tuvnes. The question is, then, what caused the decrease in cloud cover. The problem is nobody knows the answer to that. Anthropogenic climate change defenders say the increase in CO2...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by sherro01

In reply to cerescokid. Ceresco, Interesting that you comment on the quality of science using an analogy in which “leeches” has your wrong spelling. Easy to be a generalist, harder to be a specialist?...

View Article


Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by sherro01

These “extraordinary climate events” are so named because people as a group lack knowledge about climate and are unable to know what is ordinary and what is extraordinary. So, some people constructed...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Ulric Lyons

In reply to Mike. Typically, there would be more colder winters for NW Europe during a centennial solar minimum, despite the warmer AMO. And as we saw in December 2010 and in March 2013, there is...

View Article


Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by burlhenry

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003869">Javier Vinós</a>. Javier: The cloudiness decreased in 1997 because of...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Ulric Lyons

In reply to Javier Vinós. Javier said “Scientists don’t understand it because models tell them Arctic warming is due to CO2 when, in reality, it is due to a weaker polar vortex and increased heat...

View Article


Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Christos Vournas

In reply to Javier Vinós. Orbital forcing causes the global warming. Atmosphere becomes warmer. Evaporation increases. – Evaporation takes place at the surface, clouds formation in the atmosphere’s...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Javier Vinós

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003868">Bob Weber</a>. The hypothesis that a great part of the observed warming...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Bob Weber

In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2024/03/24/the-extraordinary-climate-events-of-2022-24/#comment-1003876">Javier Vinós</a>. <i>"Confirmation of this hypothesis will come...

View Article

Comment on The extraordinary climate events of 2022-24 by Dirk Visser

This Wood for Trees figure, showing the differentials of several parameters, supports the notion that the rate of temperature rise (HADCRUT data) is decreasing. The data of the past suggest that in the...

View Article


Comment on Mann v. Steyn: Round 2 by jim2

Climate Doomer Unicorn Fantasies collide hard with reality. This is happening more and more often. “Banks are living and lending on planet earth, not planet NGFS,” Berkey told the group in an...

View Article





Latest Images