Comment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Bruce Bushaw
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/09/23/natural-selection-of-bad-science-part-ii/#comment-1021665">Burl Henry</a>. "For sea levels to rise, it is necessary for ice to...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Bruce Bushaw
In reply to Burl Henry. Burl just makes up stuff. https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/150691/la-nina-times-three?fs=e&s=cl
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Burl Henry
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/09/23/natural-selection-of-bad-science-part-ii/#comment-1021670">Bruce Bushaw</a>. Bruce: And thermal expansion requires higher...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Bruce Bushaw
In reply to Bruce Bushaw. You said ice has to melt for sea level rise – that is false . So you deflect. Are you so ignorant that you don’t know what ‘thermal expansion’ means. I’ll go with senile and...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Burl Henry
In reply to Bruce Bushaw. Bruce: So, you can’t refute anything that I have stated, and are now reduced to insults!! Stupidity and ignorance are perfect descriptions of yourself. I have never...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Bruce Bushaw
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/09/23/natural-selection-of-bad-science-part-ii/#comment-1021669">Bruce Bushaw</a>. Yes I can. You stated that you have proved that CO2...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Burl Henry
In reply to Bruce Bushaw. Bruce: The current meme is that CO2 from the burning of fossil fuels will cause global temperatures to rise. However, in addition to their release of CO2, their burning also...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Christos Vournas
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/09/23/natural-selection-of-bad-science-part-ii/#comment-1021671">Bruce Bushaw</a>. Thank you, Bruce. The graph shows the Le Nino phenomenon...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Christos Vournas
In reply to Bruce Bushaw. What is the mechanism of the El Nino and La Nina cyclical phenomenon? Ok, El Nino is the continuous warming – but La Nina? Why La Nina?
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by cerescokid
In reply to Bruce Bushaw. ganon The Technician Why waste time with multiplying the rate times the years plus 1/2 x years squared x the acceleration rate when you can do it off the top of your head by...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Bruce Bushaw
In reply to Bruce Bushaw. The graph shows that La Niña does not always precede El Niño. There are many instances where 2 or 3 of one or the other occur in a row....
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Bruce Bushaw
In reply to Bruce Bushaw. Burl said “ … [SO2 emissions] rose from 68 million tons in 1955 to 141 million tons in 1979, and temperatures decreased by 0.3 deg. C., causing fears of a return to a new Ice...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Burl Henry
Christos: You ask “What is the mechanism of the El Nino and La Nina cyclical phenomenon?” First, it is NOT a cyclical phenomenon. Essentially all La Ninas are caused by a VEI4 or larger volcanic...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Bruce Bushaw
Christos, don’t pay attention to Burl. He just makes up stuff about things he doesn’t understand. The El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is indeed an oscillation, albeit somewhat stochastic. And the...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Burl Henry
In reply to Bruce Bushaw. Bruce: Everything that I posted can be verified, sorry if it doesn’t agree with your stupid misconceptions And regarding your comment about temperatures, all temperature data...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by B A Bushaw
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/09/23/natural-selection-of-bad-science-part-ii/#comment-1021671">Bruce Bushaw</a>. Burl, you are full of it, and stupid too.
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Christos Vournas
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/09/23/natural-selection-of-bad-science-part-ii/#comment-1021683">Burl Henry</a>. What I think, it is if La Nina was the oceanic regular...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by B A Bushaw
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/09/23/natural-selection-of-bad-science-part-ii/#comment-1021688">Christos Vournas</a>. Christos, read the NASA (climate.gov) article on...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Wagathon
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/09/23/natural-selection-of-bad-science-part-ii/#comment-1021684">Bruce Bushaw</a>. What is an 'ocean gyre'? Climate change alarmist Western...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by B A Bushaw
In reply to Burl Henry. Why do 3 of the largest El ninos in your paper – 1972, 1998, 2016 – occur without preceding VE4+ eruptions? Answer, volcanic activity can influence ENSO activity, but it does...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by B A Bushaw
In reply to Wagathon. No, that is what you say. Climate scientists and oceanographers would say it is caused by the Coriolis effect, Eckman spirals, wind, fresh water input, oceanic temperature...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Christos Vournas
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/09/23/natural-selection-of-bad-science-part-ii/#comment-1021688">Christos Vournas</a>. Thank you, Bruce. I followed as you adviced, and I...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by B A Bushaw
In reply to Christos Vournas. https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/monitoring/enso/technical-discussion
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Wagathon
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/09/23/natural-selection-of-bad-science-part-ii/#comment-1021690">Wagathon</a>. AI says, 'No, an increase in parts per million (ppm) of...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by B A Bushaw
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/09/23/natural-selection-of-bad-science-part-ii/#comment-1021690">Wagathon</a>. Yes, you made a false attribution to "alarmists". That makes...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Christos Vournas
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/09/23/natural-selection-of-bad-science-part-ii/#comment-1021688">Christos Vournas</a>. Thank you, B A, for good references.
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Burl Henry
In reply to B A Bushaw. B A Bushaw: El Ninos can also occur apart from volcanic eruptions, whenever atmospheric SO2 aerosol levels decrease. For 1972, there were no volcanic eruptions between 1969 and...
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by Willis Eschenbach
Gosh, Susan Solomon is distorting the truth to serve her own ends? This is my shocked face … Thanks as always for posting fascinating analyses, Dr. J. w.
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by cerescokid
“ Decelerated Arctic Sea ice loss triggered by accelerated North Pacific warming over the past decade” Just released 11/18/25 Predictably AGW is the culprit. Cue music from Jaws....
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by jim2
Wait! Actual data was examined?? Isn’t this contrary to the teachings of the Church of Global Warming?
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by Wagathon
‘The ferocious wind that spirited away the tent of the Cape Crozier party and threatened the survival of Wilson, Bowers, and Cherry-Garrard in July 1911 was a textbook example of a katabatic blizzard....
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by Russell
I’ll pass on the popcorn This isn’t vaguely interesting.
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by Chris Morris
The poorly remembered companion journey to the South Pole and Cape Crozier ones was that of the Northern Party. They wintered over without rations in a snow cave on eastern side of Inexpressible...
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by Wagathon
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/11/21/captain-scotts-1912-antarctic-tragegy/#comment-1021702">Wagathon</a>. AI reports that- 'The party was on a winter journey to collect...
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by Bill Fabrizio
Interesting piece, Mila. Thanks.
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Wagathon
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/09/23/natural-selection-of-bad-science-part-ii/#comment-1021696">B A Bushaw</a>. fyi... coprolalia symptoms may be neurological,
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by Reexamining Scott's...
[…] From Climate Etc. […]
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by R. L. Hails Sr. P. E....
Thou shalt not lie…. and I add a codicil, “Thou shalt think clearly and accept the fact that humans err.” These are universal axioms of all people, particularly for scientists, of which I am not one....
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by cerescokid
There is hope. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/G6MMSj8W0AAkvoR?format=jpg&name=medium
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by Mila
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/11/21/captain-scotts-1912-antarctic-tragegy/#comment-1021706">Bill Fabrizio</a>. Thank you, Bill!
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Wagathon
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/09/23/natural-selection-of-bad-science-part-ii/#comment-1021700">cerescokid</a>. Interesting that it apparently involves 'global climate...
View ArticleComment on Natural Selection of Bad Science. Part II by Wagathon
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/09/23/natural-selection-of-bad-science-part-ii/#comment-1021715">Wagathon</a>. 'The out-of-phase relationship between Arctic and North...
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by milazinkova
When I published my analysis of this blizzard a few months ago, I fully expected Susan Solomon to acknowledge her errors and issue a retraction. She never did, and the reason is now clear. Her silence...
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by Christos Vournas
When an object is irradiated, there is the reflection, there is the immediate IR emission, and there is the heat absorption. The object, when it is not irradiated, exhibits, a much weaker, the regular...
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by Joe K
In reply to Mila. First impression would be that a blizzard would cover a large geographic area, as such, a 00-200 mile wide swath would be expected. On the flip side, tornado’s usually are part of a...
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by milazinkova
This is a reply to Joe K’s question (the reply tab isn’t visible in the original post). Katabatic winds and tornadoes originate from entirely different processes, but they share one important feature:...
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by Joe K
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/11/21/captain-scotts-1912-antarctic-tragegy/#comment-1021721">milazinkova</a>. thanks
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by Wagathon
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/11/21/captain-scotts-1912-antarctic-tragegy/#comment-1021705">Wagathon</a>. Apparently, the party of three left because they lost to the...
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by climategrog
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/11/21/captain-scotts-1912-antarctic-tragegy/#comment-1021703">Russell</a>. Neither is you opinion but you still felt the need to share it.
View ArticleComment on Captain Scott’s 1912 Antarctic tragedy by Rob Starkey
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/11/21/captain-scotts-1912-antarctic-tragegy/#comment-1021703">Russell</a>. The evidence is how few are responding to this post. It doesn't...
View Article