Comment on Cloud Seeding History: Looking Back at the Colorado River Basin...
re: Circular Reasoning (as defined in the Urban Dictionary is a ‘logical fallacy where the conclusion of an argument is used as evidence within the argument itself, creating a loop where the conclusion...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by B A Bushaw
In reply to Joe K. Burl: “During the 300 year MWP, the Alps became ice free, and enough of the Greenland ice cap melted to permit farming.” More of Burl’s unsupported horse crap: (1) The alps were not...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by burlhenry
In reply to R.L.Hails Sr.P. E. (Ret.). B A Bushaw: Hannibal crossed the Alps on Elephants, so obviously there were more than a few mountain peaks that were ice free! “The SW coast of Greenland has not...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by “Climate science is...
[…] how Dr. Judith Curry, a deservedly enthusiastic climate scientist, begins her blog introducing the Department of Energy’s important new climate assessment. Read the […]
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by cerescokid
“ Widespread global disparities between modelled and observed mid-depth ocean currents” “ Here, using 842,421 observations produced by Argo floats from 2001-2020, and Lagrangian simulations, we show...
View ArticleComment on Cloud Seeding History: Looking Back at the Colorado River Basin...
the Wyoming study was as I remember no more than 20-40 miles downwind of a point source surface silver iodide generator. Even under Pasquill-Gifford class “A” dispersion conditions, (Class ‘A” maximum...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by B A Bushaw
In reply to burlhenry. Burl, That’s a deflection and irrelevant: Hannibal didn’t cross the alps in the MWP – it was 218 B.C. And his crossing does not mean they were “Ice free” as you called it. Also,...
View ArticleComment on Cloud Seeding History: Looking Back at the Colorado River Basin...
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/08/08/cloud-seeding-history-looking-back-at-the-colorado-river-basin-pilot-project/#comment-1019184">Chris Walcek</a>. I guess effective...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1018905">Paul Aubrin</a>. Christos Vournas wrote: <i>A cold Holocene is a...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to Paul Aubrin. Christos Vournas wrote: A cold Holocene is a confirmation of the current orbitally forced global warming. Grok: “According to available data, the Milankovitch cycles’ current...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to Paul Aubrin. Joe K wrote: Paul – I was using that cititation as an example of climate scientists failing to reconcile their data and conclusions with other known data Funny how you can’t...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1018905">Paul Aubrin</a>. Joe K wrote: <i>I gave specific citations You did...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to Christos Vournas. Christos Vournas wrote: Because the lunar surface temperatures are not distributed linearly over the entire lunar surface. Thus the 250 K number is an impossible figure....
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to B A Bushaw. B A Bushaw wrote: Why is the theoretically impossible; what theory is that? Do the surface integrals to quantify your claims. I don’t think Christos can do the surface integral....
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by B A Bushaw
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1019191">David Appell</a>. David, surely you jest. Christos can't even calculate...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to B A Bushaw. Christos Vournas wrote: Because the lunar surface temperatures are not distributed linearly over the entire lunar surface. That’s right. That’s also why Newton/Liebniz invented...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1019191">David Appell</a>. BA: I'm sure Christos can do the calculation, simply by...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to Christos Vournas. Christos Vournas wrote: It cannot be so, because it assumes Earth’s surface emits at its average surface temperature 288K. The average surface temperature is not a...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1019160">jim2</a>. jim2 wrote: <i>If Hamas cared about its own people, it...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by burlhenry
In reply to John Bates. B A Bushaw: Your DOI reference was for the period BEFORE the Holocene Climate Optimum. Not relevant! Why did you cite it? Hannibal crossed the Alps in 218 BC, during the Roman...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1019003">Wagathon</a>. Wagathon wrote: <i>There are at least two things...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1018946">David Appell</a>. Wagathon wrote: <i>China’s CO2 emissions were...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1018652">B A Bushaw</a>. clydehspencer wrote: <i>“Good god. Researchgate is...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1018632">clydehspencer</a>. clydehspencer wrote: <i>“Where is the data?”...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1018589">clydehspencer</a>. clydehspencer <i>“If they ever actually open it...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by Wagathon
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1019200">David Appell</a>. How far back in time do you believe an instrument-based...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to Wagathon. Wagathon wrote: In the 1970s it was fears of global cooling that drove Western academia and the Leftist MSM. Um, no. There was no consensus on global cooling in the ’60s and ’70s....
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1019132">Mike Haseler (Scottish Sceptic)</a>. Mike Haseler (Scottish Sceptic)...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1019129">B A Bushaw</a>. All animals are equal, but some are more equal than others.
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by B A Bushaw
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1019199">burlhenry</a>. Burl, try reading past the abstract, In particular the...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1019200">David Appell</a>. Wagathon wrote: <i>How far back in time do you...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by B A Bushaw
In reply to burlhenry. “I agree that the Alps were not completely ice free during those warm periods”. So, Why did you lie about it? SW Greenland: it was clear of ice long before the MWP with maximum...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to Jungletrunks. Jungletrunks wrote: Typing on a smartphone: “aligns” This is how you’re AI query related the word “aligns”: “Framing sunlight and CO₂ as operators invites a more dynamic and...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to Beta Blocker. Beta: https://davidappell.blogspot.com/2021/07/an-obviously-false-claim-from-cliff-mass.html
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1019056">Christos Vournas</a>. Christos Vournas wrote: <i>I have...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to Christopher Game. Christopher Game wrote: It is regrettable that this bureaucracy-sourced document still hasn’t got the dreaded/celebrated ‘equilibrium climate sensitivity’ (ECS) right....
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by David Appell
In reply to B A Bushaw. Jungletrunks wrote: “IPCC…value range of 1.8 – 5.6 C” The finest hour for scientific confidence… If that’s what the science gives…why would you have a problem with it? Do you...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by Thomas Fuller
In reply to B A Bushaw. A range of 4C when the GAT is less than 16C is a bit like saying it’s bigger than a bread basket and smaller than Yugoslavia. Well, Croatia, Serbia, Montenegro… Not really very...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by Thomas Fuller
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1018876">David Appell</a>. Umm, Mr. Appell, you might bear in mind that CO2 is not...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by cerescokid
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1019212">David Appell</a>. Appell “What is Scotland doing to help?“ They have some...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by cerescokid
“ The frequency change of 100-year flood events is often determined by fitting extreme value distributions to annual maximum discharge from a historical base period. This study demonstrates that this...
View ArticleComment on Cloud Seeding History: Looking Back at the Colorado River Basin...
[…] https://judithcurry.com/2025/08/08/cloud-seeding-history-looking-back-at-the-colorado-river-basin-pi… […]
View ArticleComment on Cloud Seeding History: Looking Back at the Colorado River Basin...
[…] From Climate Etc. […]
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by cerescokid
“ Proxy records from the last millennium in Mesoamerica suggest a widespread interval of drought at some point between the 7th and 13th centuries CE. In some records, this time period represents the...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by Joe K
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1018876">David Appell</a>. David Appell | August 2, 2025 at 7:44 pm | Reply...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by B A Bushaw
In reply to Christopher Game. Thomas Fuller: “A range of 4C when the GAT is less than 16C is a bit like saying it’s bigger than a bread basket and smaller than Yugoslavia. Well, Croatia, Serbia,...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by B A Bushaw
In reply to David Appell. Thomas Fuller: “Umm, Mr. Appell, you might bear in mind that CO2 is not the only factor influencing temperatures…”, Duh, that is so well known that many (unfortunately) drop...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by B A Bushaw
In reply to <a href="https://judithcurry.com/2025/07/29/new-climate-assessment-report-from-us-doe/#comment-1018876">David Appell</a>. Joe K, Because that is the best estimate of what the...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by Christos Vournas
There was about 250 ppm CO2 predindustrial, and the planet was already getting warmer, because of the Natural Orbitally caused forcing. – Here it is the key point: Because of the cyclical seasonal...
View ArticleComment on New Climate Assessment Report from US DOE by Wagathon
Could be a model showing Earth’s climate over time based on two independent variables- Milankovitch cycles (Earth’s orbital variations) and solar activity… independent factors of natural variation...
View Article
