Comment on Lindzen et al.: response and parry by WebHubTelescope

Jinan Cao, I noticed that you have a blog where you try do some of your calculations in depth. Where exactly do you describe the propagating slab model that is required to match your words with the math?
As it stands, you are frantically hand-waving, not realizing what will come out of the wash if you do the math bookkeeping correctly.