Mosh
I don’t follow the minute detail of the emails but Deep Climate clearly says in his second paragraph that it was Trenberth not Jones who said ‘ He Has done a lot but I don’t trust him’ and then makes disparaging remarks about McKitricks version of events.
The emails are confusingly laid out but it seems to me it was Phil Jones who made this remark.
http://foia2011.org/index.php?id=664
It therefore appears that Deep climate makes a mistake from the start. You probably follow this a lot closer than me, so who is right, Deep Climate or McKitrick?
tonyb