Comment on Laframboise on the IPCC by manacker
John Whitman As a non-involved observer, it appears to me that your proposal to create a “Climate Consortium Academica” to replace IPCC makes very good sense. Even before the Laframboise book was...
View ArticleComment on Berkeley Surface Temperatures: Released by pokerguy
tempt. writes: “It looks like you science rejectionists are now denying you’d ever questioned the temperature record in the first place. You’d never raised the issue of the “urban heat island effect”....
View ArticleComment on Berkeley Surface Temperatures: Released by denialist crank
“I’ve always felt that from a strategic POV” And that’s what’s important, that our strategies to defeat belief in CAGW be successful. Facts and science is not important, validating our prior held...
View ArticleComment on Berkeley Surface Temperatures: Released by Green Sand
Don, “Everything I have read about SST gives me much less confidence that we know anything about temperatures in and over the oceans even now, and hardly at all for the 20th century.”...
View ArticleComment on Berkeley Surface Temperatures: Released by Nebuchadnezzar
David, As long as the paper is submitted by mid-Nov and made available to the authors of the appropriate chapter then its eligible to go in, far as I know. You don’t need to make it public in any way....
View ArticleComment on Berkeley Surface Temperatures: Released by tonyb
Judith I found the other papers and read this; “We compare the distribution of linear temperature trends for these sites to the distribution for a rural subset of 16,132 sites chosen to be distant from...
View ArticleComment on Berkeley Surface Temperatures: Released by Nebuchadnezzar
It gives the authors a greater chance to avoid committing a flawed paper to the permanent record, perhaps. It gets more eyes on the analysis at an earlier stage. Some papers get mired in peer review...
View ArticleComment on Berkeley Surface Temperatures: Released by P.E.
That caught my eye, too. I wasn’t aware that this was the newspaper business.
View ArticleComment on Berkeley Surface Temperatures: Released by tonyb
Green sand Following my article on SSTs carried here http://judithcurry.com/2011/06/27/unknown-and-uncertain-sea-surface-temperatures/ I have been out in my rowing boat taking SSts. Can I get some...
View ArticleComment on Berkeley Surface Temperatures: Released by AK
I expect we should stay tuned…
View ArticleComment on Laframboise on the IPCC by M. carey
My opinion is $5 is too much to pay for a book that’s probably mostly BS.
View ArticleComment on Berkeley Surface Temperatures: Released by omnologos
Buzz – you’ve missed the whole paper.
View ArticleComment on Laframboise on the IPCC by John Whitman
M. carey, I do not know. If IPCC critics were/are or not political is irrelevent to my suggestions. Politics, per se, has less effects if the new climate assessment vehicle was not a political body...
View ArticleComment on Berkeley Surface Temperatures: Released by omnologos
How about comparing the URBAN stations to the NOT-URBAN ones? And are you really unable to see how many questions are left open because of the way a station is classified as “urban”?
View ArticleComment on Berkeley Surface Temperatures: Released by Tilo Reber
“Thats twice GISS.” Uuuuuhhhh. And that’s important why? Steven: “WRT polar stations, you best understand kridging before you spout off.” Why do I need to understand kriging? It is a mathematical...
View ArticleComment on Berkeley Surface Temperatures: Released by AK
Well, you see, because of reporting problem with too many of the stations, they don’t know the locations of many stations that closely. Urban areas comprise only about half a per cent of the Earth’s...
View Article