“No, I don’t: the whole point of the greenhouse effect is that the CO2 reduces emissions from the earth in the IR, so that, in order to balance the radiation input, the earth must heat up so as to punch more IR through the CO2.
Simple enough, and pretty obviously valid from a physics perspective.”
Dave, it’s too simple (simpletone) and not valid from a physics perspective. CO2 may reduce emmisions from Earth in the IR, but there’s evaporation/convection to balance the radiation input, at least to a degree. Furthermore, if CO2 absorbs, it emits too and enhances the atmospheric radiation to space. The atmosphere cools exclusively by radiation, as all agree. The surface cools multi-modally, again as all agree.