Comment on IPCC and traceability by Bart R

Rob Starkey

While I empathize, we should point out:

1) forecasting is not on the list of criteria;
2) correct conclusions is not on the list of criteria;
3) maturity is not on the list of criteria.

I have no idea why such obvious oversights took place with drafting the charter, but since the 20 criteria are so ill-met in the eyes of critics, it seems to me we have two different issues here.

Are you critical because IPCC reports do not adequately meet IPCC objectives, or because they don’t meet your objectives?